Best Meat Pie in Sydney

Name: Best Meat Pie in Sydney — ranking data
Creator: BestDish
License: https://bestdish.io/

The best meat pie in Sydney right now is Upper Crust (score 66 from 1,013 reviews), based on 17 venues re-ranked weekly.

Where locals actually go for meat pie in Sydney — not just what tops a Google search.

● Updated September 2026 · re-verified 17 venues this month

🔄 Re-ranked 2026-09-08: no moves since 2026-09-02 — the current order held steady.

The verdict: the best meat pie in Sydney right now is Upper Crust in Collaroy ($ price tier) (2 community mentions · 2× called the best · in 1 youtube review), ahead of Lode Pies & Pastries Surry Hills, Lode Pies & Pastries Circular Quay. That call comes from community consensus blended with Google review strength across 17 ranked venues — no pay-to-rank, updated September 2026.

The numbers: 17 venues ranked · 20,582 Google reviews analysed · median rating 4.5★ · #1 leads the field by 36 ranking points. Updated September 2026.

Best meat pie in Sydney — quick facts (September 2026)
🏆 Top pick	Upper Crust (Collaroy)
📊 Most reviewed	Harry's Café de Wheels - Woolloomooloo (2,880 reviews)
📍 Venues ranked	17 across 14 suburbs

Head-to-head: top 5 compared (September 2026)
	Venue	Suburb	Price	Rating	Known for
#1	Upper Crust	Collaroy	$	4.6★	—
#2	Lode Pies & Pastries Surry Hills	Surry Hills	—	4.6★	—
#3	Lode Pies & Pastries Circular Quay	CBD	—	4.5★	—
#4	Glenorie Bakery	Glenorie	$$	4.4★	Award-winning
#5	Watch Your Fingers Patisserie	Constitution Hill	$	4.6★	—

You've tried 0/17

#1 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Upper Crust

📍 1003 Pittwater Rd, Collaroy NSW 2097, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the sausage roll and the meat Mexican pie; both never disappoint.

$📍 Collaroy

★ 4.6 (1,013 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 2 community mentions · 2× called the best · in 1 YouTube review

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#2 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Lode Pies & Pastries Surry Hills

📍 487 Crown St, Surry Hills NSW 2010, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the wagyu pie; the bolognese pie is the sleeper hit.

📍 Surry Hills

★ 4.6 (982 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 2 community mentions

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#3 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Lode Pies & Pastries Circular Quay

📍 Shop CQT.05B, 33 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the croissant and meat pie; both are flaky and flavor-packed.

📍 CBD

★ 4.5 (189 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 2 community mentions · dish praised in 1 of 5 recent Google reviews

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#4 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Glenorie Bakery

📍 4/930 Old Northern Rd, Glenorie NSW 2157, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the burger and fries; do not skip the pies

Award-winning🌱 Gluten-free options$$📍 Glenorie

★ 4.4 (2,636 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 1 community mention · 1× called the best · dish praised in 1 of 5 recent Google reviews

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#5 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Watch Your Fingers Patisserie

📍 5 Emma Cres, Constitution Hill NSW 2145, Australia

🍴 What to order: Order the pork belly with apple and the beef bourguignon pie.

$📍 Constitution Hill

★ 4.6 (376 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 1 community mention · 1× called the best · dish praised in 1 of 5 recent Google reviews

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

Local maker · sponsored

Made in Melbourne, like your next feed

3D printed planters, pencil holders & desk organisers — printed to order in Melbourne, shipped Australia-wide.

formada3d.com →

#6 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Flour and Stone

📍 53 Riley St, Woolloomooloo NSW 2011, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the lamington; the lemon dream cake is equally essential.

Bakery classic$$📍 Woolloomooloo

★ 4.6 (1,347 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#7 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

The Proper Pasty Company

📍 Shop 12/99 Military Rd, Neutral Bay NSW 2089, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the Cornish pasty; the sausage rolls and scotch eggs are must-tries.

📍 Neutral Bay

★ 4.9 (124 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#8 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Romeo's Pie Cafe

📍 3/201 Pacific Hwy, St Leonards NSW 2065, Australia

🍴 What to order: Get the chunky steak pie; the chicken and mushroom is excellent too.

🌱 Gluten-free options$📍 St Leonards

★ 4.7 (236 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#9 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Ken's Humble Pie Shop

📍 32 Coral St, The Entrance NSW 2261, Australia

🌱 Vegetarian options$📍 The Entrance

★ 4.8 (965 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#10 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

The Pie Tin

📍 1a Brown St, Newtown NSW 2042, Australia

$📍 Newtown

★ 4.3 (1,155 reviews) on Google Maps

Why it ranks: 1 community mention

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#11 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Pie in the Sky

📍 1296 Pacific Hwy, Cowan NSW 2081, Australia

$📍 Cowan

★ 4.5 (2,614 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#12 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Mountain High Pies

📍 293 Great Western Hwy, Wentworth Falls NSW 2782, Australia

🌱 Vegan options$📍 Wentworth Falls

★ 4.5 (2,837 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#13 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Bourke Street Bakery Surry Hills

📍 633 Bourke St, Surry Hills NSW 2010, Australia

Bakery classicGourmet$$📍 Surry Hills

★ 4.5 (2,135 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#14 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Banksia Bakehouse

📍 225 George St, Tenancy 4 Grosvenor Place, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia

📍 CBD

★ 4.5 (657 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#15 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Blessed Fruit Pies

📍 103 Miller St, North Sydney NSW 2060, Australia

📍 North Sydney

★ 4.9 (115 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#16 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Patchett's Pies

📍 2-6 Ewan St, Mascot NSW 2020, Australia

$📍 Mascot

★ 4.5 (321 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

#17 of 17 meat pie spots in Sydney

Harry's Café de Wheels - Woolloomooloo

📍 Cowper Wharf Roadway, Woolloomooloo NSW 2011, Australia

$📍 Woolloomooloo

★ 4.3 (2,880 reviews) on Google Maps

🛵 Uber Eats 🛵 DoorDash 📅 Book

Common meat pie questions in Sydney

What's the best budget meat pie in Sydney?

Upper Crust is the top-ranked budget ($) option in Collaroy — #1 overall for meat pie.

Where's the best meat pie in Sydney for a special occasion?

Glenorie Bakery ($$ price tier) is the highest-ranked venue worth the splurge, in Glenorie.

What's the best vegetarian-friendly meat pie in Sydney?

Ken's Humble Pie Shop is the highest-ranked venue with confirmed vegetarian options, in The Entrance.

Where can I get gluten-free meat pie in Sydney?

Glenorie Bakery is the highest-ranked venue with confirmed gluten-free options, in Glenorie.

Keep exploring: Related: 🐟 best fish & chips in Sydney · 🍗 best chicken parma in Sydney · 🍳 best brunch in Sydney · 🥪 best sandwiches in Sydney. Meat Pie elsewhere: Melbourne · Brisbane · Perth · Adelaide. Q&A: your meat pie questions answered. Nationally: best meat pie in Australia, 14 cities compared. Also: head-to-head: the top two compared · best value ($) picks. See the data report.

How we rank

We machine-scan the community discussions (Reddit threads and food guides in the search index) for each venue's name, then blend: community mentions 70% (mentions ×10, 'the best' superlatives ×6, normalised) + Google review strength 30% (rating above a 3.8 baseline, weighted by review volume). Global fast-food and dessert franchises are excluded. This page is auto-mined; flagship pages get hand curation on top.

Frequently asked

What is the best meat pie in Sydney?

Upper Crust currently ranks #1 for meat pie in Sydney — 2 community mentions · 2× called the best · in 1 YouTube review.

What is the best cheap meat pie in Sydney?

Upper Crust is the highest-ranked budget option in Collaroy.

Where is the best meat pie in the Sydney CBD?

Lode Pies & Pastries Circular Quay is the top-ranked meat pie spot in the CBD (Shop CQT.05B, 33 Pitt St, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia).

How does BestDish rank meat pie in Sydney?

Venues are scored by blending community mentions from local discussions with Google review strength (rating above a 3.8 baseline, weighted by review volume). Global chains are excluded.