The data behind this ranking: BestDish has scored 19 meat pie venues in Melbourne, drawing on 6,995 Google reviews across 14 suburbs. The median venue score is 14 (out of a top score of 57); the median Google rating is 4.5★. Current #1: Baketico by Wonder Pies Brunswick with a score of 57. Updated September 2026.
| Venues ranked | 19 |
| Google reviews analysed | 6,995 |
| Median BestDish score | 14 |
| Score range | 8–57 |
| Median Google rating | 4.5★ |
| Suburbs represented | 14 |
No ranking moves of 2+ places since the last snapshot — the current order held steady.
We machine-scan the community discussions (Reddit threads and food guides in the search index) for each venue's name, then blend: community mentions 70% (mentions ×10, 'the best' superlatives ×6, normalised) + Google review strength 30% (rating above a 3.8 baseline, weighted by review volume). Global fast-food and dessert franchises are excluded. This page is auto-mined; flagship pages get hand curation on top.
Scores and review counts on this page are computed at build time from the exact same dataset that powers the live meat pie ranking — nothing here is a separate or hand-picked figure.