Which is better for gelato in Melbourne: Piccolina Gelateria or Pidapipó CBD?

Piccolina Gelateria ranks higher on BestDish (80 vs 63 points). Pick Pidapipó CBD if it has more Google reviews (1,982 vs 1,032) or it's the cheaper option.

🍜 BESTDISH

Piccolina Gelateria vs Pidapipó CBD

the top two for gelato in Melbourne, compared properly

● Updated September 2026

The verdict: Piccolina Gelateria beats Pidapipó CBD for gelato in Melbourne — it leads our ranking by 17 points (3 community mentions · 3× called the best · seen in 1 tiktok/ig post · dish praised in 3 of 5 recent google reviews). Pick Pidapipó CBD if it has more Google reviews (1,982 vs 1,032) or it's the cheaper option.

Piccolina Gelateria vs Pidapipó CBD — gelato in Melbourne (September 2026)
	Piccolina Gelateria	Pidapipó CBD
BestDish rank	#1 🥇	#2 🥈
BestDish score	80	63
Google rating	4.5★	4.5★
Google reviews	1,032	1,982
Price tier	$$	$
Suburb	CBD	CBD
Known for	—	—
Community mentions	3	2

Go deeper: Piccolina Gelateria dossier · Pidapipó CBD dossier · the full Melbourne gelato ranking

How we score: Google review strength (rating above a 3.8 baseline weighted by volume), blended with community-consensus mining on high-traffic pages. No pay-to-rank.